Why
the need to use animal organs for human transplants? Is there even such
a need? No, rather it's a technological solution proposed for an urgent
but non-scientific supply and demand problem, namely, shortage
of organs. More people die on waiting lists than receive transplants.
This fait accompli is apparently all that's necessary to breathe life
into the need for Xenotransplantation - Wikipedia,
i.e., animal organ transplant into humans. However, accepting this fait
accompli at face value is not only dangerous but also quite
disingenuous for the following reasons.
Why Xenotransplantation Isn't An Appropriate Response To The Organ Crisis: It Doesn't Address The Underlying Issue
Transplant waiting lists keep growing. Not too few donors. Rather too many potential recipients. While donations and transplants remain steady, numbers waiting for transplants grow year-on-year (1)
in developed countries. Scenario is palpably ghastlier in poorer
countries, where forget transplants, even dialysis is usually beyond
reach for many organ failure patients.
Why is the need for transplants increasing though? This is typically swept under the carpet as increasing morbidity rates.
But why are morbidity rates increasing in the first place, especially
in developed countries? Somehow this, the very crux of the matter, gets
short shrift in both the biomedical literature and popular media.
~80% of those on waiting lists need kidneys due to ESRD (end-stage renal disease, Chronic kidney disease - Wikipedia). Increasing numbers of organ failure patients have ESLD (end-stage liver disease) (2). Most common predisposing factors are alcoholic liver cirrhosis (3), diabetes (4) and obesity (5). Clearly lifestyle issues
drive need for more transplants. That is not to imply all transplants
are for lifestyle-mediated chronic diseases but rather that much of the
annual increase is driven by such preventable increases in morbidity.
Bad
diets and sedentary lifestyles are apparently impossible to change as
are the underlying socioeconomic structure and accompanying culture that
increasingly make these the norm the world over. In other words,
preventable, consumption-driven practices that predispose to
transplant-requiring chronic health conditions have been allowed to seed
and settle into society, no questions asked. Let's state the obvious.
Where's the profit in prevention? Changing the culture, especially diet
and lifestyle, is hard work, and even less appetizing for those
habituated to feeding on the profits to be made from chronic diseases.
Thus, once such preventable
diseases have taken root, capital intensive high-tech solutions to
treat them including even xenotransplants become all the rage. Few
mention that the organ crisis is nothing new, having existed since at
least the 1980s (6).
Evidently a case of the tail wagging the dog, the prevailing hegemony
is thus to hardly ever allude in the first place to why need for organs
is increasing and how to reduce it but rather to bemoan the organ crisis
and contrive ever more creative and ethically challenging ways to
increase the organ pool.
These creative though
ethically challenging solutions started with expanding the definition of
appropriate transplant sources. Originally, only deceased donations
were allowed. Then definition of death expanded to include the legal
fiction of two types of death, circulatory death (traditionally used)
and brain death (7) so organs could be harvested from more bodies.
Obviously brain death 'decriminalizes the harvesting of beating hearts'
(8). Then donations from the living got the nod. Any surprise organ
trafficking and global black market in organs followed suit (9), especially among the multitude too poor to feed themselves or their children (10, 11, 12)? After all their bodies are all they can offer the market.
Some
European countries such as Greece and Spain have even taken the
creative urge to extremes, embracing the currently fashionable Nudge theory - Wikipedia by introducing opt-out consent (13),
where people are automatically presumed to have given consent to
post-death organ donations unless they specifically take the trouble to
opt-out while they're still alive. Supposed rationale is we humans are
well-intentioned but lazy. Well-intentioned as in of course, we intend
to choose to donate our organs after death but somehow we're too lazy to
ever get around to giving the necessary legal heft, i.e., consent, to
our good intentions.
And of course, desperation increasingly permeates the medico-legal culture which now explores using even infected (14) and mismatched kidney transplants (15).
Meantime, the ongoing US drug overdose epidemic provides a ghastly
book-end to the organ crisis by increasing organ availability (16).
Why Xenotransplantation Isn't A Solution To The Organ Crisis: Immunological Rejection & Infectious Disease Risk
And
so we arrive at xenotransplantations, a path to unlimited supply of
donors and their organs at least in theory. After all, what other
purpose for this planet and its various denizens but to serve the
human's needs. Unfortunately for the human, in this instance biology has
turned out to be a more intractable partner.
- Immunological rejection remains a vexing issue decades into the project with little sign of improvement (17) but that's not the only concern.
- SARS (Severe acute respiratory syndrome - Wikipedia) in 2003, Bird flu (Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 - Wikipedia) in 2007, Swine flu (2009 flu pandemic - Wikipedia) in 2009, MERS (Middle East respiratory syndrome - Wikipedia) in 2012, Ebola virus disease - Wikipedia in 2014 and Zika fever - Wikipedia in 2015, these are major infectious disease outbreaks since just the mid-2000s, many of them Zoonosis - Wikipedia, jumps from animals to humans. Obviously then known and even as yet undiscovered viruses being transmitted from the animal donors to organ recipients remains an ever-present danger (18). Yes, a high-powered group led by Harvard geneticist George Church used CRISPR-cas9 (CRISPR - Wikipedia) to delete potentially harmful DNA sequences at 62 sites in pig cells (19) but that was just a preliminary proof of principle study. Do we really need to concoct yet another path for more pathogens to jump species and thrive in humans, which may well turn out to be the risk with Xenotransplantation?
In other words,
technocracy encourages solutionism rather than trying to understand the
fundamental crux of the problem, which in this case is spiraling rates of lifestyle-driven chronic diseases. Reducing them would automatically reduce the need for transplants in the first place (see below from 20, emphasis mine).
'Medical strategies to prevent end-stage organ failureThe prevention or delay of end-stage organ failure must be accomplished to reduce the need for organ transplantation and to achieve national self-sufficiency. This approach is especially relevant to low-income countries, where resources can be better used for other pressing medical needs. Thus, education programmes about organ donation for the public and the media should also address the maintenance of a healthy lifestyle. Early detection and prevention of diseases leading to end stage organ failure, such as diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and kidney disease, is necessary.'
Bibliography
2.
Williams, Roger, et al. "Addressing liver disease in the UK: a
blueprint for attaining excellence in health care and reducing premature
mortality from lifestyle issues of excess consumption of alcohol,
obesity, and viral hepatitis." The Lancet 384.9958 (2014): 1953-1997.
3.
Williams, Roger, et al. "Implementation of the Lancet Standing
Commission on Liver Disease in the UK." The Lancet 386.10008 (2015):
2098-2111. https://www.researchgate.net/pro...
4.
Wild, Sarah H., et al. "Type 2 diabetes and risk of hospital admission
or death for chronic liver diseases." Journal of hepatology 64.6 (2016):
1358-1364.
5. Williams, Bronwen, Michelle
Clayton, and Joanne Bosanquet. "Obesity: a growing threat to liver
health." Gastrointestinal Nursing 13.Sup10 (2015): S16-S19.
6.
Miller, Melanie. "A proposed solution to the present organ donation
crisis based on a hard look at the past." Circulation 75.1 (1987):
20-28. http://circ.ahajournals.org/cont...
7.
Truog, Robert D., and Franklin G. Miller. "Changing the conversation
about brain death." The American Journal of Bioethics 14.8 (2014): 9-14.
8.
Epstein, Miran. "Constructing the Legal Concept of Death: The
Counterhegemonic Option." The American Journal of Bioethics 14.8 (2014):
45-47.
9. Scroll, Sanjay Nagral, August 3, 2016. Better buy than die? The unfortunate enduring saga of organ sales in India
10.
Epstein, Miran. "The ethics of poverty and the poverty of ethics: the
case of Palestinian prisoners in Israel seeking to sell their kidneys in
order to feed their children." Journal of medical ethics 33.8 (2007):
473-474. https://www.researchgate.net/pro...
11.
Budiani‐Saberi, Debra A., and Francis L. Delmonico. "Organ trafficking
and transplant tourism: a commentary on the global realities." American
Journal of Transplantation 8.5 (2008): 925-929. https://www.researchgate.net/pro...
12.
Danovitch, Gabriel M., et al. "Organ trafficking and transplant
tourism: The role of global professional ethical standards—The 2008
Declaration of Istanbul." Transplantation 95.11 (2013): 1306-1312. https://www.researchgate.net/pro...
13. The Economist, Nov 20, 2008. Opting out of opting out
14. Stat, Elie Dolgin, March 18, 2016. Surgeons to test use of infected kidneys for transplants
15.
Orandi, Babak J., et al. "Survival benefit with kidney transplants from
HLA-incompatible live donors." New England Journal of Medicine 374.10
(2016): 940-950. http://www.nejm.org/doi/pdf/10.1...
16. The Guardian, Amanda Holpuch, May 1, 2016. Drug overdose epidemic has driven increase in organ donors, data shows
19.
Yang, Luhan, et al. "Genome-wide inactivation of porcine endogenous
retroviruses (PERVs)." Science 350.6264 (2015): 1101-1104. http://arep.med.harvard.edu/pdf/...
20.
Delmonico, Francis L., et al. "A call for government accountability to
achieve national self-sufficiency in organ donation and
transplantation." The Lancet 378.9800 (2011): 1414-1418. http://www.who.int/transplantati...
https://www.quora.com/Can-we-genetically-modify-animals-to-procure-organs-for-humans/answer/Tirumalai-Kamala
No comments:
Post a Comment